The lowest existing home sales since 2010 mean fewer homes are changing hands nationally, not that New York City prices have collapsed. The national number is not the New York market. I'm Nile Lundgren, founder of the Lundgren Team at SERHANT., with $550M in sales. The job this month is negotiating, not waiting on a headline.
If you want a straight read on what this means for your next move in New York, talk to the Lundgren Team at SERHANT..
What do the lowest existing home sales since 2010 actually show?
They show a drop in closings, not a drop in the national median price.
The National Association of REALTORS (NAR) reported on November 12, 2026, that existing-home sales in October ran at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 3.75 million. That is down 5.5% from September and down 8.8% from a year earlier, the lowest pace since August 2010.
Here is the rest of what the report actually said:
- Unsold inventory was 1.59 million units, equal to a 5.1-month supply.
- The median existing-home price was $416,700, up 0.4% from a year earlier.
- Sales held steady month over month in the Northeast, and were down from a year ago in all four regions.
- Distressed sales were 2% of transactions.
Lawrence Yun, NAR's chief economist, said home sales fell to their lowest level since August 2010, and that "there could be sizable pent-up demand if mortgage rates decline." That is his comment, not a forecast I am making.
Is a 2010 low in existing home sales a price collapse?
No. It is a volume story. Fewer people closed, and the national median price was still up.
NAR said the $416,700 median marked the 40th consecutive month of year-over-year price increases. Distressed sales, meaning foreclosures and short sales, were 2% of transactions, a share NAR called historically low.
A slow year of sales is not the same thing as owners being forced out. Those are different conditions. I am not going to predict where prices go next, in New York City or anywhere else. I am telling you what this print actually measured.
In the Northeast, sales held steady month over month at an annual rate of 470,000, and were down 4.1% from October 2025. The Northeast median price was $519,600, up 3.2% from a year earlier. That is still a regional figure, not a New York City one, and it is not a price break.
What does this mean for NYC buyers?
It means you should not take a national sales pace and treat it as your building.
NAR does not publish a New York City number in this report. The closest regional read is the Northeast, where sales held steady month over month and the median price was still up. That is not a substitute for the building you are walking through.
My view, as I said in October: "Interest rates affect a lot of markets that don't necessarily affect New York City." I also said, "I feel like the market is softer, but you have to get out there and make a lot of offers."
A national scare can thin the room. That is my read, not a statistic. A buyer who is ready, and who can carry the payment at today's terms, is negotiating against a quieter field than the headline suggests. That is not a reason to buy because of a report. It is a reason not to sit out because of one.
If you are weighing a rate delay, I already wrote that up in Should I wait for mortgage rates to drop? For the broader timing question, see Is now a good time to buy luxury real estate in NYC?.
When you are ready to look at homes, start with our current New York listings.
What does this mean for NYC sellers?
It means you are not looking at a forced-sale market, and you may still have to negotiate.
NAR's distressed share was 2% nationally. That is not a New York City figure, but it is the opposite of a wave of owners being pushed out. My view on why many owners stay put: "A lot of people have great rates. ... why would they sell?"
I also said in October that "it's also been challenging for sellers, cause they're gonna have to take a little bit less," and that I feel like the market is softer. That is still how I see it. A quieter national tape does not mean you skip the work of pricing to the market you have.
What should a buyer or a seller do this month?
Read the print, then go back to your own numbers and your own building.
For a buyer: if this is the right home and the payment works today, get out and make offers. That is my view, not a promise about rates or prices, and not a push to buy because of a headline. Ask your lender to run the payment at today's terms. I do not give lending advice.
For a seller: price with evidence, and be ready to negotiate. A national sales low is not a reason to freeze, and it is not a reason to guess at a number the market will not pay.
For tax questions, talk to your CPA. For a legal question, talk to your attorney. For a loan question, talk to your lender.
FAQ
Is the housing market crashing?
I am not going to predict a crash, or promise there will not be one. The October NAR print is a volume low, with a national median price that was still up and distressed sales at 2%. That is not what a forced-sale tape looks like. I wrote more on how I read crash headlines in Is the housing market going to crash?
Should I wait for rates?
Not if waiting is your whole plan. Nobody can promise you next month's rate. I walk through that decision in Should I wait for mortgage rates to drop?
Is New York City different from the national sales report?
Yes. The NAR report is a national existing-home sales print. It is not a New York City report. My view: "Interest rates affect a lot of markets that don't necessarily affect New York City."
How do I contact Nile Lundgren about buying or selling in NYC?
Call (917) 453-4526 or use the contact page at nilelundgren.com/contact.
Nile Lundgren, founder of the Lundgren Team at SERHANT., with $550M in sales and nearly two decades of experience. Licensed in New York and Florida. RealTrends Top 1 percent. Cast member of Netflix's Owning Manhattan.
Call (917) 453-4526 or contact the Lundgren Team at SERHANT. at https://nilelundgren.com/contact