Search

Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Explore Our Properties
Nile Lundgren in a New York City apartment with Midtown Manhattan and Central Park in the windows

Should I Sell or Rent Out My Apartment in NYC?

Nile Lundgren  |  November 16, 2026

Whether you should sell or rent out your apartment in NYC depends on your building's rules, your carrying costs, your timeline, and what a sale would bring now, not on last quarter's rent print alone. I'm Nile Lundgren, founder of the Lundgren Team at SERHANT., with $550M in sales.

If you want a number for your own apartment first, request a custom valuation from the Lundgren Team.

What did last quarter's Manhattan rent prices actually show?

They showed a sharp year-over-year increase in Manhattan, and a citywide asking-rent high for the Realtor.com series. They did not answer the sell-or-rent-out question for your unit.

Realtor.com Economic Research, in its New York City Rental Report for Q3 2026, published October 27, 2026, reported:

  • Manhattan's median asking rent was $5,375, up $411, or 8.3%, from a year earlier. Manhattan led the surge, with the fastest percentage increase among the boroughs.
  • Citywide, the median asking rent was $3,785, up $162, or 4.5%, from a year earlier. Realtor.com said this was the highest rent level since its data series began in 2019Q2.
  • Brooklyn's median asking rent was $4,197, up $197, or 4.9%, year over year.

That is asking rent for units listed on Realtor.com last quarter, not a sale price, and not a rent roll for your building. A borough median is context. Your floor, your condition, and your building set the rent that would actually apply. Q3 is one print. It is not a forecast.

If you are on the other side of this question, and you are deciding whether to rent or buy, I already wrote that up in Is it better to rent or buy in NYC?. This page is for the owner.

Should I sell or rent out my apartment in NYC just because asking rent is up?

No. A high asking-rent print can make holding look easy. The decision still comes down to four questions only you can answer.

First, what does your building actually allow? Co-op board policies and condo bylaws vary. I am not going to tell you what yours says. Read the documents, and talk to your attorney before you assume you can rent the unit out.

Second, how do your carrying costs sit against a realistic rent, not a citywide median? Maintenance or common charges, taxes, insurance, vacancies, and the work of managing a rental all belong in that comparison. Run the numbers with your accountant. I am not going to do return math for you here, and I do not give tax advice.

Third, how long are you prepared to hold? A rental is a job with a timeline. A sale is a clean exit. If your life is moving in a year, that is a different decision than if you want to keep the asset.

Fourth, do you want to manage a rental, or do you want to be done? Both can be the right call. Neither is automatic because Manhattan asking rent led the city's surge last quarter.

What does thin inventory mean if I want to sell?

It means a well-priced sale can still find a buyer, even while asking rents are high.

My view, as I said in October: "In Manhattan, inventory is scarce." "And nobody's selling." Scarcity cuts both ways. It is one reason rents have room to run. It is also why a seller who prices to the market they have is not waiting on a default plan to rent the unit out.

If you list, price to the market you have. If you hold, do it because the plan works for you, not because a median asking rent looked like a reason to wait.

A national sales headline is not your building, either. I walked through that in What do the lowest existing home sales since 2010 mean for NYC buyers and sellers?. The local question is simpler: if you listed this apartment, correctly, would today's buyer still show up? In a thin market, the answer is often yes. That does not mean you should sell. It means selling is still a real option, not a closed door.

How should I decide what to do next?

Get the facts on your unit, then choose on purpose. You do not have to decide from a headline. You decide from your documents, your numbers, and your timeline. If those three line up behind a rental, hold and do it properly. If they line up behind a sale, list it and price it. If they do not line up yet, get the missing piece before you move.

Confirm what your building allows, with your attorney. Put your actual carrying costs next to a realistic rent, with your accountant. Get a current view of what the apartment would sell for. Then decide whether you want to hold and rent, or sell and exit.

If you want to walk through that with us, call (917) 453-4526 or contact the Lundgren Team at SERHANT..

FAQ

Can I rent out my co-op?

It depends on your building. Co-op board policies and condo bylaws vary, and I will not pretend to know yours from here. Check your documents and talk to your attorney before you plan on a rental.

Should I wait for rents to rise more?

I would not build the plan on it. Nobody can promise you next quarter's asking rent, including me. Decide from your rules, your costs, your timeline, and what a sale would bring now.

How do I get a value for my apartment?

Request a custom valuation from the Lundgren Team at nilelundgren.com/home-valuation, or call (917) 453-4526.

How do I contact Nile Lundgren about selling or renting out an apartment in NYC?

Call (917) 453-4526 or use the contact page at nilelundgren.com/contact. For a custom valuation, use nilelundgren.com/home-valuation.

Nile Lundgren, founder of the Lundgren Team at SERHANT., with $550M in sales and nearly two decades of experience. Licensed in New York and Florida. RealTrends Top 1 percent. Cast member of Netflix's Owning Manhattan.

Call (917) 453-4526 or contact the Lundgren Team at SERHANT. at https://nilelundgren.com/contact

Planning your next move? Talk to Nile.

Nile Lundgren, founder of the Lundgren Team at SERHANT., has $550M in sales and is recognized among the RealTrends Top 1 percent. A cast member of Netflix's Owning Manhattan, he works with buyers, sellers and investors across New York and Florida, including Miami and Tampa. Tell him what you are planning and his team will follow up.

Smiling bald man with a trimmed beard in a blue suit and patterned tie, arms crossed.

Prefer to talk? Call (917) 453-4526. Selling? Get a custom home valuation at nilelundgren.com/home-valuation

 

Get in Touch

Call or Visit Us

Bringing together a team with the passion, dedication, and resources to help our clients reach their buying and selling goals.

Contact Us

Follow Us On Instagram